Guides & Advice

The Dangers of Joint Property

Published: 3rd February 2021
Area: For the individual

“How is your joint property held” is a question we ask every client undertaking estate planning or making a will.

The answer can potentially have very significant consequences, particularly where the family home is the main asset.

For some, the ability to hold property as either joint tenants or tenants in common may be very familiar concepts. For others, the decision of how to hold the family home has often been made many years ago or was not something ever actively considered.

Other clients have undertaken estate planning many years ago, which resulted in their property being held as tenants as common. However, when the couple have moved, the new property has inadvertently been purchased as joint tenants, potentially undermining any estate planning they have put in place.

Where property is held as joint tenants, on the death of one owner, the property passes automatically to the other, regardless of the provisions of that person’s will.

But in contrast, where property is held as tenants on common, when one person dies, the share belonging to them passes in accordance with the terms of their will.

Many family homes are held as joint tenants, as this is often seen as the “default” for married couples and although this may work well for many people, it is not always the best option.

Considerations for the future

Consider a second marriage, where the first to die wishes to protect their share of the property for the children of previous relationships. If the home is held as joint tenants, the surviving spouse has complete control after the first death – they could give the property away or they could leave it in their Will to their own children or to a new spouse if they remarry. If they die without a Will, the laws of intestacy will decide who will inherit this on their death and this will not include step-children.

The possible unintended consequences of holding a property as joint tenants are clearly demonstrated by a recent case where a married couple were both found dead at their home. It was unclear who had died first and each had a daughter from a previous relationship.

The couple held their home (and their bank account) as joint tenants, meaning that whoever died second would inherit the other’s share.

Where it cannot be determined who has died first, the law considers this to have been the older person, in this case the husband. As a result of this, the wife was deemed hold all the assets at her death and her daughter inherited everything. The husband’s daughter inherited nothing. Had the property been held as tenants in common instead, each daughter would have received half.

How it affects estate planning

Holding property as tenants in common can also sometimes be useful even where the ultimate intended beneficiaries are the same for each joint owner.

Many people choose to include Nil Rate Band Trusts in their Wills on the first death, not least because this allows up to £325,000 to be held outside the Estate of the survivor, providing protection of this sum from care fees. If the main asset is the family home, it is often necessary to ensure that the share belonging to the first to die passes under their Will in order to have enough value to make full use of this Trust. This will not happen where property is held as joint tenants.

These are the key features of joint tenants vs tenants in common but whether they are pros or cons can be subjective and frequently depends on individual circumstances. It’s important to obtain legal advice before committing to one option over another so that you know that you’re making the right choice for you and your family.

Contact us

For further information contact Kathleen Ryan or another member of the private client team in your local office.

From inspirational SHMA Talks to informative webinars, we also have lots of educational and entertaining content for life and business. Visit SHMA® ON DEMAND.

Our free legal helpline offers bespoke guidance for any queries on family and private matters. We also have a team of experts on hand for a range of subjects, from employment and general business matters through to director’s responsibilities, insolvency, restructuring, funding and disputes. Available from 10am-12pm Monday to Friday, call 0800 689 4064.

How can we help?

Our expert lawyers are ready to help you with a wide range of legal services, use the search below or call us on: 0330 024 0333

SHMA® ON DEMAND

Listen to our SHMA® ON DEMAND content covering a broad range of topics to help support you and your business.

Key contract and pre-contract considerations | Avoiding insolvency in the construction industry

4 Nov

Laura Taylor, Associate | Frank Bouette, Partner
Key contract and pre-contract considerations | Avoiding insolvency in the construction industry

In this series, we will cover, pre-contract checks, insolvency/Termination clauses; step in rights, retention […]

Charity: Whose art is it anyway?

10 Nov

Andrew Wilkinson, Partner
Charity: Whose art is it anyway?

In this webinar, we will talk through the often tricky legal issues that arise, […]

Retirement housing: Why is the supply of housing with care so limited in Scotland and what will it take to boost it?

23 Nov

Louise Drew, Partner & Head of Building Communities
Retirement housing: Why is the supply of housing with care so limited in Scotland and what will it take to boost it?

In this webinar we will be joined by Andrew Fyfe, Co-founder of Sovereign Property […]

The warning signs: what to do when they appear and how to minimise risk | Avoiding insolvency in the construction industry

24 Nov

Kate Onions, Partner | Gareth Hegarty, Legal Director
The warning signs: what to do when they appear and how to minimise risk | Avoiding insolvency in the construction industry

The construction market is supposedly booming since COVID-19 restrictions were lifted, but is suffering […]

Our Latest Thoughts

All the latest views and insights on current topics.

Our latest edition of Life Times magazine

15 Oct

For the individual

Our latest edition of Life Times magazine

Read article Right Arrow

Witnessing a Will Online: The Problems with Remote Signing

7 Oct

Wills

Witnessing a Will Online: The Problems with Remote Signing

Read article Right Arrow

Top tips for Making a Will

7 Oct

Private Capital

Top tips for Making a Will

Read article Right Arrow

Government Announces Adult Social Care Reforms

20 Sep

Family

Government Announces Adult Social Care Reforms

Read article Right Arrow

LPA reform proposals: a snapshot

10 Sep

Private Client

LPA reform proposals: a snapshot

Read article Right Arrow