With Stewart Argo, Associate – Commercial
In this webinar, we will give some background to the reasons behind notices, assignment and variation clauses and key considerations when drafting these into a contract.
Please do let us know of future topics that you are interested in, or for more information about our webinars please contact us and you can view past webinars at SHMA®ON DEMAND.
Our thoughts
All the latest views and insights.
The New Procurement Act Principles
19 Jan
Commercial
The New Procurement Act Principles
On 26 October, the Procurement Bill completed its passage through the UK parliament and […]
Philipp v Barclays Bank UK plc – a step too far! The Supreme Court reinforces the prevailing scope of the Quincecare duty
21 Jul
Corporate & Commercial
Philipp v Barclays Bank UK plc – a step too far! The Supreme Court reinforces the prevailing scope of the Quincecare duty
The landmark case of Philipp v Barclays Bank UK plc [2023] UKSC 25 sought […]
SHMA® ON DEMAND
All the latest on-demand content.
The Shakespeare Marathon and Half Marathon
21 Apr
The Shakespeare Marathon and Half Marathon
We are proud to once again be sponsoring the Shakespeare Marathon and Half Marathon […]
Making sure you’re compliant
24 Apr
Ewan Carr, Legal Director | Helen Dyke, Legal Director
Making sure you’re compliant
Employment law is constantly on the move and HR professionals and in-house employment lawyers […]
Webinar transcript
(Please note this is auto-generated and un-edited)
Hi, I'm Stewart Argo, an associate in the commercial and IP department here at Shakespeare Martineau, I help clients with a wide range of commercial issues, including commercial contracts, IT, intellectual property, and protection, and assist clients with the legal documentation underpinning that commercial transactions.
0:25
So, welcome to today's training webinar, the third part of a three part series, on what my Closest. In this final part, I'll be discussing neige says, Assignment and Variation.
0:37
On your screen, you will see the chat icon. Please use this to ask any questions, and we will respond to you directly after this training webinar.
0:44
So Tony ... fast contract asylum, certain statutory provisions may apply, that may not deal with issues, such a Former have noticed, message delivery, untamed receipt.
0:55
Notice of vision should be clear as to the format of the notice. How it can be given, when it is delivered.
1:02
It is important to create the provisions simple, if you are likely to give notice, as you do not want it to be difficult for you to give notice.
1:10
So therefore, avoid prescriptive requirements where possible.
1:14
For example, in the case of bought an international investments limited invention, group, PLC, and others, the court of Appeal held that. while the notice, because did not specify to whom within the company delivery should be made, personal slavery was affected by delivery to someone authorized Sufism notice. In this case, it was held at services validly affected by leaving a document with the receptionist.
1:36
So from the perspective of the party giving notice, it was preferable for the notice provision to specify the races simply be made to the company. Rather than a specified direction. As there was arrested, notice, would not reach that specified direct.
1:50
If it's simply made to the company, then it could be anyone who's authorized receive it and that is very wide.
1:57
There are also a couple of other recent cases which demonstrate the court's interpretation of restaurants is tougher twice controls and Climates International, which was a case where Gnosis with not strictly in accordance with the Contracts for Nurses clothes.
2:12
Because I'm not other things. The required name recipient of the notice had retired, and so notice could not be delivered to him.
2:18
The court had held notice had been adequately get had been adequately given because the recipient was no doubt that claim may be brought and its grounds and so could act accordingly.
2:29
However, this can be contrasted with stable or unstable and tinkler where where the recipient required sat there was not present, because I've noticed out to refer to a tax claim.
2:43
Talked to the potential Irish Taxation on a potential client, not the actual client, and created an incorrect paragraph cross-reference and outlined possible ... route HMRC not the vendor's liability.
2:56
So with this in mind, will contained receipt. It's a contract does not contain any demonstrate provisions. Notice Assessed upon receipt the onus on send that to prove note is received by the intended recipient.
3:09
It is important from the perspective of the Perkins person giving notice that the noted provisions are drafted, it says, to be clear, as to when delivery takes place and to ensure that is not difficult for about to give notice.
3:21
Deemed receipt provisions help the parties serving a notice by removing the need to prove that the nice arrived or when it arrived.
3:29
The party giving notice just needs to evidence when and how they center.
3:34
Service of notices by e-mail can be problematic, because it carries a number of additional risks. For example, the nice being set by third party in e-mail arriving late or not tau, the e-mail being unintelligible on delivery or contain chains format, which may alter the meaning of the content of the notice, I'll say it may be comparatively easy for to falsify an e-mail compared to most traditional hard copy documents.
4:03
Therefore, in order to reduce these risks, you might consider amending a nice provision two to include provision to define clearly when delivery occurs.
4:13
For example, when enters in, addresses, inbox or read when it's read by the addressee and all make games conditional upon the send us taking certain steps. Example, sending my posts, and he has a PDF attachment, appropriate texts in the e-mail subject line to identify the notice specified.
4:33
Addressees, again, bearing in mind that you don't want to, if you're giving the tissue that wanted to stumble across any fault, onerous, kind of formality requirements need to make sure that the steps and approaches are appropriate fulvia corpses.
4:54
Some of those provisions in the drafting, you should take care to ensure drafting is clear as to for the method ascending, and dangerous ... avoid being prescriptive.
5:04
It should be easy for our party to give nice and close and dress across. parties can be sure that delivery by any permitted methods will reliably bring the notice to the other party's attention.
5:14
Tell you now to Simon other dealings, with the contract as silent as to assignment and dealings. Part is can usually assigned moez charged or to declare a trust or its rights under the contract without consent. It's very unlikely that restriction will be applied.
5:29
Generally, parties can use self-control to perform their duties unless A restriction can be applied. So, for example, if a person performances requirement of the contract, then usually that situation where the calls would apply a restriction on subcontracting.
5:46
The benefits of using an assignment on the data is close are as follows: the parties are able to control who receives the benefit of that performance. Sample. competitors band personal organizations are desirable sessions, associations, passengers, who you might not wish to receive the benefits forms to the contract. And secondly, the parties are able to control who carries out the contract for them, again, issue customer. He's got a chosen supplier. Then, you want to have control of supply chain in, particular, that, then, it's useful to, to include such close.
6:23
So when considering or drafting a clause dealing with assignment dealings, consider whether there is an absolute restriction on transfers or if consent of the other party is required and what is that it is appropriate.
6:34
It's also consider whether there should be any exceptions on the restriction, for example, do you need to be able to transfer companies, not competitors?
6:45
Or if, if you are aware of any potential business, sales in the future, then should express provide for for those to be kind of exceptions to the restriction, Should also consider whether any conditions on the transfer within the goals, for example, in relation to ... bus contract with.
7:06
Or if there are any kind of notification requirements that are needed for, for soccer chatting. for example.
7:16
Whilst you have a wide scope to restrict the salmonella dealings, you should be aware that it is not absolute and there are limits on the effectiveness of an assignment on the dating to close. These are imposed by the business contract terms soldered receivables regulation in 20 18.
7:33
Under these regulations, anytime in a relevant business contract entered in into on or after the 31st of December 2018 does not prohibit which restricts the son of receivables is automatically ineffective. So, it doesn't mean that accruals itself is unenforceable. It just means that it will be ineffective to, to prevent the assignment of receivables, the ....
7:58
So, moving on to variation.
8:00
So, under common law, parties may vary a contract by mutual agreement as long as consideration is given, all the variation agreement is executed as a date in the absence of consideration any required formalities. For example, if you are executing as a deed, that aid can only be varied by date.
8:21
Therefore, to assist with contract management is often useful to agree, express provision, for gray a document and changes, and also require an variations to the contract ought to be made in writing.
8:36
This helps to prevent unintended formal variations, or undocumented changes.
8:42
Including a variation clause I will, not of itself into a contract management by the parties, it is just a tool in the contract management section.
8:51
You should also be aware that to manage contract company internally and with external parties also.
8:59
Well it isn't much to consider when it comes to traffic variation close. It is important to note that the full effect of a closed venting, all variations when it comes to implementing agreed variations. The recent case of rock Advertising limited and MWB, Business Exchange Centers limited shows, such across inventing all variations will normally invalidate changes made without following the expressly agreed formalities for making changes to the contract.
9:24
In this case, the contract between the Parties Container Clause, which stated All variations to this license must be great, set out in writing, and signed on behalf of Fact. It's very standard variation from. Rock was a licensee of premises who have accumulated a raise of licensed face under the contract. The licensee proposed or Vice chairman of payments and Franco contended that MWB license so had already agreed to vary the license.
9:52
MWB instead consider the Release schedule, mainly parizeau and locked walk out on premises, fail to pay the agreed arrears terminated the license.
10:05
MWB sued for the arrays and what counter-claims for damages for wrongful exclusion.
10:13
Supreme Court agreed. With rock. There wasn't all variation to as to vary the payments.
10:21
However, the Supreme Court refused to lauzon no modifications close, to be ignored. the formal agreement by the Parties had no effect at MWB was not bound by the revised schedule.
10:33
Therefore, if a contract includes a no, all modifications calls, artists want to bury the agreement, or they will need to expressly ways and no modification scrolls.
10:44
The Supreme Court did go on to acknowledge that the enforcement of a no modification or modifications close, contained within the risk the party could act on the contract as varied, and then find itself unable to enforce it.
10:59
They said that the safeguard against injustice in such circumstances lie in the various doctrines of Istanbul.
11:05
However, Istanbul could not be so broad as so as to destroy the advantage of certainty to which the party stipulated when they agreed on terms, including the no modifications calls.
11:18
Therefore, there had to be some words or conduct unequivocally representing.
11:22
The variation was valid, notwithstanding its informality, and something more would be required for the purpose zandy inform promise itself.
11:33
That brings us to the end of this webinar. I hope you found it useful and relevant? If you'd like discuss any point in more detail or have any other queries, please do contact me. My details are on the slide and I'll be happy to help out.
11:45
Finally, please do visit. SH MA on demand on our website to access recordings of our webinars, annotator, my talks. And please do join in on our conversations on LinkedIn and Twitter.
How can we help?
Our expert lawyers are ready to help you with a wide range of legal services, use the search below or call us on: 0330 024 0333