Director liable for fraudulent trading for not investigating VAT fraud - ignore HMRC at your peril

Blog | Banking & Financial Services
Published: 3rd March 2022
Area: Corporate & Commercial

Share This

A recent High Court decision (JD Group Ltd [2022] EWHC 202 (Ch)) has found a director liable for fraudulent trading when he was aware that the company was participating in VAT fraud and deliberately failed to investigate.   This decision has ramifications for directors and companies.

Background to the case

The company started trading in baby clothes, and later in mobile phones. When HMRC assessed its 2005/2006 tax return it declined its claim for tax relief in respect of a series of related import and export transactions, the effect of which was VAT fraud. HMRC suggested that the company undertake various steps to avoid this, such as investigating counterparties.

The liquidator subsequently brought a claim against the director for fraudulent trading (sec. 213 Insolvency Act 1986). The liquidator relied on HMRC’s analysis of the VAT fraud.

The court confirmed that the liquidator had to satisfy a two-stage test. First, to demonstrate the director's subjective state of knowledge; and then to show that the director's conduct was dishonest based on the objective standards of ordinary decent people (Bilta (UK) Ltd (In Liquidation) v Natwest Markets Plc [2020] EWHC 546 (Ch)).

The director argued that he did not know the company was participating in a VAT fraud. He claimed the company had robust pre-transaction due diligence processes and, as a result, he believed the transactions were genuine.

The outcome

The court held that the director's defence was not credible. There was no evidence that due diligence was being carried out, the transactions were back-to-back and often entered into before payment was received. The evidence showed that the transactions were uncommercial.

The court concluded that the director was, therefore, aware that the company was participating in a fraud, and that the director deliberately decided not to carry out due diligence and other steps suggested by HMRC. The director's conduct was dishonest by the objective standards of ordinary decent people and he was, therefore, liable for fraudulent trading.

The court ordered the director to contribute an amount equal to HMRC's claims in the liquidation for unpaid VAT to the company’s assets, plus a misdirection penalty (for misdeclaration in the company's 2005/2006 tax return). This was on the basis that, had the VAT fraud not occurred, the company would not have been liable to HMRC.

Our advice?

Our advice to directors facing a similar situation would be to implement (and never ignore) measures suggested by HMRC to mitigate the risks of companies being implicated in tax fraud, and consequently mitigate a director's risk of finding themselves subject to a similar claim.

Get In Contact

Frank specialise in providing managed solutions in financially distressed scenarios to assist OMBs, companies, directors, lenders, investors and other stakeholders, as well as insolvency office holders.

Banking & Financial Services

Now, more than ever, contingency planning has never been more essential. Our full-service team can offer technical expertise, commercial acumen and unrivalled eye for detail around your business options, funding arrangements or any other challenges you may currently be facing.

Our Thoughts

All the latest thoughts and insights from our team

Intervention of Khokhar Solicitors

22 Jun

SRA Intervention

Intervention of Khokhar Solicitors

Devereux & Co has been closed down by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (‘the SRA’). […]

Read article Right Arrow

Shakespeare Martineau appoints expert director to company secretary team

20 Jun

Corporate & Commercial

Shakespeare Martineau appoints expert director to company secretary team

Shakespeare Martineau has appointed a new director to help grow and enhance the reputation […]

Read article Right Arrow

SHMA® On Demand

All the latest on-demand content

Agriculture: diversifying or leasing your land to create habitat banks

6 Jul

Peter Snodgrass, Partner & Head of Agriculture

Agriculture: diversifying or leasing your land to create habitat banks

We know that biodiversity net gains provide a significant opportunity for landowners to diversify […]

Register Right Arrow

Teachers’ Pension Scheme – strategic issues independent schools need to think about

20 Jul

Esther Maxwell, Legal Director | Emma Glazzard, Solicitor

Teachers’ Pension Scheme – strategic issues independent schools need to think about

Webinar Teachers’ Pension Scheme – strategic issues independent schools need to think about In […]

Register Right Arrow