Guides & Advice

Villiers vs Villiers: A case of ‘divorce tourism’

Published: 6th July 2020
Area: For the individual

Villiers vs Villiers: A case of ‘divorce tourism’

Why choosing your divorce location matters

On 1st July 2020, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of Mrs Villiers, a woman wishing to take advantage of ‘divorce tourism’. This relates to divorcing in a location that may give you a more favourable settlement.

Her husband, Mr Villiers, wanted the divorce to be dealt with in Scotland alone, where they had lived for most of their married lives. However, Mrs Villiers desired for the maintenance case to be heard in England, where she had been living for some time after the separation.

It is rare for divorce cases to reach the heights of the Supreme Court, but this one was unusual. So, what does the ruling mean for you?

What is ‘divorce tourism’?

Simply put, divorce tourism is where people apply to have parts of their divorce handled in different jurisdictions – i.e. a different geographical location – England vs Scotland, for example.

What are the benefits of using different jurisdictions?

English and Scottish law are not the same. Scottish courts deal with divorces in a much more formulaic way than their English counterparts. South of the border, the courts take a more discretionary approach and award settlements that they feel are appropriate depending on individual circumstances.

Jurisdiction is critical in any divorce and it’s important to explore all options available. If it’s possible to have proceedings heard in a country with a potentially more favourable legal system – England and Wales, for example – then this would obviously be a wise move for anyone looking to commence divorce proceedings. However, it’s important to be aware that it’s often necessary to meet a number of criteria around residency and citizenship to have this choice.

Is ‘divorce tourism’ a guaranteed win?

While this Supreme Court ruling is cause for celebration for Mrs Villiers, the victory comes with a significant safety warning. Having her maintenance appeal heard by the English, rather than Scottish courts, is still no guarantee that she will get what she wants.

In addition, there could be certain challenges to overcome if various aspects of the case are determined in different jurisdictions.

What does this case mean for the future of UK family law?

Ultimately, whilst this is an interesting legal point, a question mark remains around how many people this particular decision will affect. The costly level of litigation means it is unlikely to lead to a sudden uptick in people looking to make the most of ‘divorce tourism’.

Of course, divorce tourism isn’t only applicable to those filing for divorce in England and Wales versus Scotland, there are multiple and complex nuances across jurisdictional territories around the entire world. However, there are many reasons why London is long thought of as the ‘divorce capital of the world’.

The divorcing process can be exhausting and stressful enough for separating couples, without having a Supreme Court ruling to contend with. With such complexity about where divorce proceedings take place and the difference it can make, it is worth seeking counsel well before these first steps are taken.

Contact us

No matter where you are on your journey, we can help to support and guide you through. Contact us confidentially today by calling 0330 024 0333, or filling out our enquiry form and someone will get in touch with you shortly.

SHMA® ON DEMAND

Listen to our SHMA® ON DEMAND content covering a broad range of topics to help support you and your business.

Farming, family and “fairness” – how to mitigate the risk of inheritance disputes

5 Apr

, | Andrew Wilkinson, Partner
Farming, family and “fairness” – how to mitigate the risk of inheritance disputes

It is no coincidence that many of the most significant court inheritance disputes are […]

Agriculture: Protecting family wealth with a pre-nuptial and post-nuptial agreement

3 Mar

, | Helen Bowns, Partner
Agriculture: Protecting family wealth with a pre-nuptial and post-nuptial agreement

Pre and post-nuptial agreements can be very valuable, especially to those who are concerned […]

Avoiding messy split ups – co-habitation agreements for couples planning or currently living together

18 Oct

Katherine Marshall, Partner | Matt Parr, Legal Director | Tom Ansell, Partner
Avoiding messy split ups – co-habitation agreements for couples planning or currently living together

As lockdown forced some couples to live together this last family webinars will see […]

When two families become one – practical guidance on estate protection, wills and guardianship appointments

11 Oct

Katherine Marshall, Partner | Matt Parr, Legal Director | Debra Burton, Partner
When two families become one – practical guidance on estate protection, wills and guardianship appointments

This is the second webinar in our series of three and will focus on […]

Grandparents rights: when there is a family dispute involving grandchildren

1 Oct

Katherine Marshall, Partner | Matt Parr, Legal Director | Tom Ansell, Partner
Grandparents rights: when there is a family dispute involving grandchildren

The first of our series of three family webinars will align to Grandparents Day […]

Charities: Defending 1975 Act claims in a pandemic – do charities have “needs”?

18 May

Andrew Wilkinson, Partner | Alistair Spencer, Associate
Charities: Defending 1975 Act claims in a pandemic – do charities have “needs”?

Has the current Covid context led to charities being in greater need and altered […]

Our latest thoughts & insights

All the latest views and insights to help you navigate your personal matters.

Spring 2022 Consumer Finance Update

17 Jun

For the individual

Spring 2022 Consumer Finance Update

Spring 2022 Consumer Finance Update Eddie Flanagan discusses the latest updates from the consumer finance […]

Read article Right Arrow

Charity expert vows to ‘stand up for the sector’ after committee appointment

10 Jun

For the individual

Charity expert vows to ‘stand up for the sector’ after committee appointment

Charity law and governance expert Catherine Rustomji has been elected to sit on the […]

Read article Right Arrow

What’s in a name? Your holiday could be riding on it

18 May

For the individual

What’s in a name? Your holiday could be riding on it

Read article Right Arrow

No-fault divorce becomes legislation on Wednesday 6 April 2022

5 Apr

Family

No-fault divorce becomes legislation on Wednesday 6 April 2022

Read article Right Arrow

Birmingham law firm’s family team bolstered with specialist partner appointment

16 Mar

Firm News

Birmingham law firm’s family team bolstered with specialist partner appointment

Read article Right Arrow

A simple guide to defamation – what is it and how to bring and protect against a claim

9 Mar

Litigation & Dispute Resolution

A simple guide to defamation – what is it and how to bring and protect against a claim

Read article Right Arrow

Legacy loop: spring edition 2022

8 Mar

For the individual

Legacy loop: spring edition 2022

Read article Right Arrow

How can we help?

Our expert lawyers are ready to help you with a wide range of legal services, use the search below or call us on: 0330 024 0333