Guides & Advice

How to handle construction disputes effectively

Published: 4th March 2021
Area: Construction

The delays and disruption caused by both COVID-19 and Brexit have left construction businesses concerned about the disputes that could arise as a result.

With an increase in disputes expected over 2021, companies need to know how best to manage them, including how to avoid unnecessary escalation.

Read more about what the construction sector could look like in 2021.

Keeping delays and disruption to a minimum

New levels of administration have had to be introduced on all construction sites, including the implementation of social distancing and a switch to digital methods of communication.

These changes were inevitably going to cause delay and disruption, and when Brexit was added into the mix, complications only grew. To mitigate any delay and / or disruption, areas for concern should be identified and monitored, with a solution or alternative option ready, if needed.

Common disputes for construction businesses

There are three common types of disputes that are emerging at present, these include:

  • Delay claims – The need for social distancing, and difficulties sourcing materials, has meant some contractors are struggling to finish projects on time. As such, issues surrounding whether employers are entitled to liquidated damages or whether contractors are entitled to extensions of time and loss and expense associated with the delay, are surfacing regularly.
  • Claims for payment – An increasing number of companies are facing financial difficulties. Contractors and sub-contractors in financial distress are more likely to make potentially inflated applications for payment. If the employer does not want to pay the amount applied for, they must issue a valid payment / pay less notice. If they don’t, they leave themselves open to a smash and grab adjudication.
  • Defects claims – Site inspections have been more limited over the past year meaning defects may be more likely. Plus, legacy claims relating to defects in works that were completed many years ago have also begun to emerge. If a construction company hasn’t kept records of these projects, then it will be difficult to deal with these claims.
Stopping disputes from escalating

Early prevention is always better than a late cure, so it is essential to address any issues as soon as possible. Effective communication is key to this, including keeping those upstream (whether employer or main contractor) updated as to any potential delays or disruptions.

Flexibility is also important, with contract renegotiations often being a productive way forward. However, any changes that are agreed must be documented to avoid satellite disputes occurring later on.

What are the types of dispute resolution?

Sometimes, disputes cannot be resolved through communication alone. When this happens, there are a number of routes that can be followed to reach a settlement. Adjudication is the most common form of dispute resolution in the construction industry, but although it is efficient (usually taking little more than a month from start to end), it does come with time and at least some financial cost implications.

If adjudication isn’t the best option for you, there are two alternative options that can be just as effective:

  • Mediation - Issues are discussed with a professional mediator who acts as a neutral voice assisting the parties in reaching a negotiated resolution via a process known as ‘shuttle diplomacy’ (which just means the mediator ‘shuttles’ from a discussion with one party to a further discussion with the other party in trying to bridge the gap). In order to have a productive / meaningful settlement discussion, mediation must be done at the right time, when the rights and wrongs of both parties are clear with all the key issues having been distilled.
  • Early neutral evaluation – A third-party decision maker is appointed who hears each party’s submissions and then offers their view on the likely outcome of the trial. This usually has no binding effect but can be an effective way to start meaningful negotiations (particularly if one party has a misguided view of the merits of its position acting as a ‘sense check’).
We can help you manage, avoid and resolve contractual issues

All aspects of the construction industry have had to face a host of challenges during the pandemic, with delay and disruption being a common theme. However, the disputes that do arise from this don’t have to unduly strain or breakdown working relationships. Keeping clear channels of communication open, following the correct contractual processes and being open to flexibility can help the industry to thrive once more.

If you would like advice on how to handle and resolve a construction dispute then our specialist construction law team can help – contact Kate Onions for guidance and support.

Our construction team is ranked as a Leading Firm in the Legal 500 2021 edition.

From inspirational SHMA Talks to informative webinars, we also have lots of educational and entertaining content for life and business. Visit SHMA® ON DEMAND.   

Our free legal helpline offers bespoke guidance on a range of subjects, from employment and general business matters through to director’s responsibilities, insolvency, restructuring, funding and disputes. We also have a team of experts on hand for any queries on family and private matters too. Available from 10am-12pm Monday to Friday, call 0800 689 4064.   

How can we help?

Our expert lawyers are ready to help you with a wide range of legal services, use the search below or call us on: 0330 024 0333

SHMA® ON DEMAND

Listen to our SHMA® ON DEMAND content covering a broad range of topics to help support you and your business.

Charities: Defending 1975 Act claims in a pandemic – do charities have “needs”?

18 May

Andrew Wilkinson, Partner | Alistair Spencer, Associate
Charities: Defending 1975 Act claims in a pandemic – do charities have “needs”?

Has the current Covid context led to charities being in greater need and altered […]

Employment Tribunal: Top tips and tactics for the Education sector

20 May

David Browne, Partner | Esther Maxwell, Legal Director
Employment Tribunal: Top tips and tactics for the Education sector

This stimulating and highly practical discussion will cover the top tips that institutions need […]

Later Living: Unlocking development potential for Retirement Living

26 May

Louise Drew, Partner & Head of Building Communities
Later Living: Unlocking development potential for Retirement Living

Our webinar will explore the typologies of housing available, the design, funding and planning […]

Employment: Post-pandemic working arrangements

27 May

Michael Hibbs, Partner | Lubna Laheria, Solicitor
Employment: Post-pandemic working arrangements

What will working arrangements look like in a post-pandemic future? We look at the […]

Later Living: Build to Rent & Retirement Living

27 Apr

Louise Drew, Partner & Head of Building Communities
Later Living: Build to Rent & Retirement Living

Our panel discusses the differences and synergies between the markets and lessons that can […]

Agriculture: Partnership Agreements

22 Apr

Peter Snodgrass, Partner & Head of Agriculture | Jennie Wheildon, Legal Director
Agriculture: Partnership Agreements

This bite size webinar is intended help you firstly identify a partnership and then […]

Fire and Re-hire – the controversy and the law

21 Apr

Matt McDonald, Partner
Fire and Re-hire – the controversy and the law

So why is fire and re-hire controversial, and what do employers need to consider […]

National Design Code: Beauty is in the eye of the beholder

24 Mar

Richard Cooke, Associate Director | David Pendle, Planning Director
National Design Code: Beauty is in the eye of the beholder

Design is currently a hot topic of debate, with the Government consulting on a […]

Our Latest Thoughts

All the latest views and insights on current topics.

The new JCT Dispute Adjudication Board – What does this mean for you?

10 May

Construction

The new JCT Dispute Adjudication Board – What does this mean for you?

Read article Right Arrow

98 homes get the go-ahead following land acquisition in Derbyshire

5 May

Real Estate & Planning

98 homes get the go-ahead following land acquisition in Derbyshire

Read article Right Arrow

How can universities implement green goals to reach net zero emissions?

27 Apr

Education

How can universities implement green goals to reach net zero emissions?

Read article Right Arrow

National Design Code: What is ‘beautiful’?

26 Apr

Marrons Planning

National Design Code: What is ‘beautiful’?

Read article Right Arrow

Managing the risk of insolvency in your supply chain

21 Apr

Construction

Managing the risk of insolvency in your supply chain

Read article Right Arrow